Supporters of the Magpies are progressively regarding Eddie Howe's squad as an unreliable ally. When everything clicks, they transform into the very entertainers, unleashing breathtaking exhibitions. However, on other occasions, once-dependable players like their midfield linchpin and his teammates simply fail to appear.
Compounding this issue is a late-game strategy suffused by a pronounced streak of panic. Before their trip to Manchester United, the statistics tell a sobering story: the team has dropped thirteen vital top-flight points from winning situations this season and are without a clean sheet in 10 straight matches across all competitions. Claiming victory at their famous stadium would be only their second domestic triumph on the road this year.
On the flip side, a loss has only come once in their last six Premier League encounters, and although sitting in a modest eleventh position, they are a only 6 marks away from the coveted top four. Factor in an impending two-part League Cup semi-final against Manchester City and a decent chance of moving on to the Champions League knockout phase, and it is simpler to appreciate the manager's cautious positivity.
“It's not only about problems,” remarked the team's head coach. “We have assets too. The perspective here is decidedly optimistic currently. I realize everybody else may hold a divergent take, but I feel we're making progress.”
The question is: can this collection of players match – or even surpass – the heights of the previous campaign's cup glory and European-qualifying standing? Balancing a hectic fixture list hinders.
The resulting fatigue could explain the failure to maintain a superb opening 45-minute showing against Chelsea, eventually letting slip a two-goal advantage to tie 2-2. Likewise, it is possibly the explanation for a lackluster display in a damaging loss to local rivals Sunderland, where the team looked sluggish just days after a tough European excursion.
Although on-field instruction is clearly the manager's forte, the constant schedule of two games a week matches has drastically cut into valuable training sessions. This hinders the squad's tactical adjustment to playing with summer signing Nick Woltemade up front, rather than the departed their former star. Although immensely talented, Woltemade lacks the same electric counter-attacking speed or relentless defensive work rate.
In fact, the side's previously effective pressing game has occasionally broken down. Injuries to crucial component the Brazilian midfielder have been a factor, while high-profile arrivals Anthony Elanga and the English midfielder have had difficulties settling since their combined £90m+ moves.
If a move to a back three might arguably assist the cause, a severe backline injury crisis renders that difficult. Key full-backs will be missing for the next key fixtures, straining the team's resilience.
When playing at their energetic best, they look virtually unstoppable. The issue is maintaining that intensity for the entire 90 minutes. The often-seen plan B of dropping deep into a deep-lying counter-attacking formation has at times been self-destructive.
“That match became chaotic at 2-2,” conceded the manager. “However the intention was going for the victory. We always go out to win.”
What seems required is a balanced approach – with superior ball retention, a midfield capable of controlling the pace, and a sensible readiness to occasionally accept a point. However, a ambition to challenge on every competitions is pushing limited squad numbers to their limit.
It may appear sacrilegious to some, but a more selective strategy in the cup competitions in the initial stages could have alleviated the current schedule pile-up. With critical European and league matches on the agenda, the necessity to strategically choose focus areas is growing increasingly apparent.
Eddie Howe recognized the scale of the challenge ahead. “When you're involved a club of this size, the pressures are big. Every moment's pivotal. There is progress to be made in the league. We're in the League Cup semi-finals, we want to go through in the Champions League and perform in the FA Cup.
“We're moving in the correct path, but we have lots of work to do to become the regularly winning side we envision. The ability to string together winning runs has escaped us so far.
“The objective is to attain those levels we are aware we're capable of. I believe that the confidence to achieve it is returning. Yet now we have to demonstrate it. It's not all bad right now, but the next few weeks will shape a great deal.”